Rosie Duffield and the Transphobia Row 

By Anne Belworthy


Reading recent reports about the transphobia row between the Canterbury MP, Rosie Duffield, and the leader of Canterbury City Council, Ben Fitter-Harding, made me wonder just how much longer the Labour Party hierarchy will be glad that Canterbury elected Ms Duffield as the first ever Labour MP for the city? It has certainly made many local Labour Party members begin to wonder if it was such a good result. 

Keir Starmer made Duffield a Labour Whip but very shortly after withdrew it because she broke the rules of lockdown. 

Duffield used parliamentary privilege to make accusations against a previous lover/fiancé of domestic abuse. Yet the best way that she could have helped other women, who may be in an abusive relationship, was to have gone to the police and reported the abuser and that would have raised the profile of domestic abuse. Instead, she used her parliamentary position to make it all about her, and thus prevented the man or his family from having a right of reply to the accusations. Again, this was a headline grabbing event – all about Rosie Duffield. 

She has attracted social media attention by the treatment of staff and now has entered amazingly into the trans issue without personal involvement or with in-depth knowledge of the issue; involving herself in social media debate by agreeing with some very unpleasant statements on the issue. 

Now she has managed to get more publicity for her views from the local newspapers with a row on the issue with the leader of the city council. 

I have been a Labour Party member for over 60 years and I have never known a Labour MP to court such unpleasant media attention as Rosie Duffield has done. She does not take advice, disengages herself from members who ask her questions she doesn’t like, and fails to discuss issues that she chooses not to, which is very unwise behaviour for a relatively new member of the party. 

At a time when the Labour Party is in turmoil with the internal disruption that Keir Starmer and his General Secretary have caused by their widespread suspension and expulsion of party members on, very often, dubious accusations of anti-semitism. To now bring in a transphobic debate is probably not something they would have wished for, and they must be beginning to wonder if they really need more of Ms Duffield’s unwelcome publicity.


ABOUT

Anne Belworthy is a veteran Labour campaigner, presently living in Herne Bay. A member of Labour’s Herne Bay branch, she is the delegate to the North Thanet constituency. She was the chair of Canterbury & District Pensioners’ Forum for 16 years.


Whitstable Views: How You Can Help

  • Make sure you share and like our articles on Facebook and Twitter, and whatever other social-media platforms you use.
  • Follow the site to get regular updates about new articles when they appear. Press the “Follow” icon in the bottom right hand corner of your screen and that will take you to the option to sign up. (It disappears as you move the text down, then reappears as you move it back up again!)
  • Leave comments on the site rather than on Facebook. Let’s get a debate going. All of our contributors are willing to engage with you if you leave a comment.
  • To all writers out there, we would LOVE you to make a contribution. Read our submissions page for details on how to go about that: https://whitstableviews.com/submissions/
  • Finally you can donate. As little as £1 would help. Details on the donations page here: https://whitstableviews.com/donate/

8 Comments

  1. davidharnold57

    I am also a gay labour party member, Bermondsey, and after reading your piece i am no wiser as to what it is that Rosie Duffield has done. You give no evidence whatsoever.

    I suspect that you’re merely running with the pack and will now refuse to answer my request for evidence of RD’s transphobia and will simply abuse me

    Like

      1. David Arnold

        This is all just chinese whispers! I cannot pin down any transphobia, just a lynch mob working each other up into wilder and wilder realms of hysterical hyperbole. And all Orchestrated by that awful owen jones!

        Like

  2. Janine Longley

    As an MP she has questioned, in public, the rights and protections afforded to trans people set out within the Equalities Act 2010. If this isn’t transphobia, I don’t know what is!

    Like

      1. matzz60

        In the text of the article “Reading recent reports about the transphobia row between the Canterbury MP, Rosie Duffield, and the leader of Canterbury City Council, Ben Fitter-Harding.., ” the word ‘reports’ is in grey because if you click on it, it is a link to the newspaper reports in question.

        Like

  3. DuffieldOut

    There’s no proof of her transphobia, is there? None at all?

    Rosie, only appearing on a transphobic Youtube channel, talking about how transphobic she is, in her own words. Clown.

    Like

  4. christopherjamesstone

    A number of people have attempted to discuss the trans issue on this thread. Let us make this clear: if you read the article, it is not about trans issues, it is about Rosie Duffield hijacking those issues for self- promotion and publicity. The writer does not express a view on trans issues. This is what she says: Rosie Duffield has “now has entered amazingly into the trans issue without personal involvement or with in-depth knowledge of the issue; involving herself in social media debate by agreeing with some very unpleasant statements on the issue.” That’s as far as it goes. Other issues are mentioned, such as her breaking lockdown, or using parliamentary privilege to make accusations against her ex. The trans issue is a complex and highly controversial one and, for the moment at least, we do not wish it to be discussed on this site. People on both sides tend to get very abusive towards each other very quickly. That is the reason that certain comments have been blocked. Future comments on the issue will also be blocked.

    Like

Comments are closed.